In a new federal court filing, Meta Platform’s (FB) Facebook is holding fast on its position that its social media company is no monopolist. For that reason, the company argues, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission shouldn’t be allowed to go forward with an antitrust lawsuit against it.
“[R]ather than plead facts that could show monopoly power, [FTC] relies on inapposite statistics and admitted assumptions to dress up conclusory speculation,” Facebook said in its reply brief filed Wednesday in support of its position that the agency failed to craft a viable lawsuit.
The FTC's lawsuit accuses Facebook of engaging in an illegal "buy or bury" scheme by snapping up competitors like Instagram and WhatsApp in order to eliminate its competition.
At the heart of Facebook's argument for dismissing the case is its assertion that the company lacks dominant market share in the markets alleged by the FTC: "personal social networking" or "personal social networking services (PSNS).” The company also said the FTC failed to show Facebook used acquisitions of Instagram and WhatsApp to exclude competitors and harm consumers, and that the FTC’s vote to authorize an amended complaint after an initial one was thrown out was invalid.
“The FTC still has not identified a single commercial actor, anywhere, that recognizes a PSNS market as defined, much less tracks PSNS usage in a way that might permit assessment of market shares,” the filing states. Additionally, the company goes on to say, “no plausible factual support exists” for the agency’s claim that it has power to raise prices or restrict output in the purported market.
Judge James E. Boasberg, a federal judge in Washington, D.C., tossed the FTC's initial complaint in June after concluding the agency fell short of defining Facebook as a monopolist; however, the judge allowed the agency to file an amended lawsuit.
In its revised claims, the FTC argues that the social media giant stands in a special class of social networking services, apart from the likes of TikTok and Twitter. Those other services do not compete directly with Facebook, the FTC argues. It also points to Comscore data that tracks the overall time users spend online as a way to support that Facebook holds a monopoly in the Personal Social Networking Services market.
However, Facebook responded: “The Comscore data do not even purport to measure PSNS and thus do not qualify as ‘underlying facts that might substantiate’ the FTC’s assertion."
According to the FTC, Facebook used its acquisitions of WhatsApp and Instagram, which the agency’s own regulators approved, to block competition that in turn, harmed consumers. The company purchased Instagram in 2012 for $1 billion and WhatsApp in 2014 for $19 billion.
“Unable to maintain its monopoly by fairly competing, the company’s executives addressed the existential threat by buying up new innovators that were succeeding where Facebook failed,” the agency said in its amended complaint.
In response, Facebook doubled down on its position that because its services are free, the FTC fell short of showing that the services would be less expensive with more competition, or that output would have been greater, but for the alleged illegal monopolistic behavior.
Facebook also raised concerns that FTC Chair Lina Khan should have been recused from voting on the agency’s decision to authorize the amended complaint. It characterized the 3-2 vote as “tainted” and “invalid.”
Alexis Keenan is a legal reporter for Yahoo Finance. Follow Alexis on Twitter @alexiskweed.
Follow Yahoo Finance on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Flipboard, SmartNews, LinkedIn, YouTube, and reddit.
Find live stock market quotes and the latest business and finance news
For tutorials and information on investing and trading stocks, check out Cashay
Bitcoin's long-term momentum is starting to fade, which could limit price gains this month, but some remain bullish for the short term. Rosh Singh, co-founder and CEO of crypto trading platform Quadency, discusses why he thinks bitcoin could reach $100K by the end of 2021 and what metrics he's watching to support this prediction.
Cryptocurrency exchanges, wallet service providers, lenders and mining companies can now advertise their services on Facebook and Instagram.
MOSCOW (Reuters) -Russia's state communications regulator Roskomnadzor has filed cases against U.S. tech firms Google and Meta that could see fines imposed on their annual turnover in Russia, a Moscow court said on Friday. Roskomnadzor in October threatened both Alphabet's Google and Meta's Facebook with fines based on a percentage of their annual turnover for a repeated failure to delete content that Moscow deems illegal.
"There are too many automatic posters and not enough human posters," Eric Schmidt told Barron's.
Facebook parent Meta Platforms Inc. attempted again to undercut the Federal Trade Commission's antitrust lawsuit against the social media giant with its latest federal court filing Wednesday. "[R]ather than plead facts that could show monopoly power, [FTC] relies on inapposite statistics and admitted assumptions to dress up conclusory speculation," Meta said in a filing. "The FTC still has not identified a single commercial actor, anywhere, that recognizes a [personal social networking services]
The decision is a blow to Texas lawmakers who alleged Facebook, Twitter and Google’s YouTube censor right-wing views and former President Donald Trump
A federal judge has blocked Texas from enforcing a law that aimed to block social media companies from banning users based on political views. Judge Robert Pitman issued the order Wednesday in favor of two industry associations that sued to block the Texas law. "Social media platforms have a First Amendment right to moderate content disseminated on their platforms," Pitman wrote. The order underscored that social media platforms are "privately…
Meta's (formerly, Facebook's) experimental app division, the NPE team, is shifting gears. Over the years, the largely Menlo Park-based team launched and retired a number of experiments, ranging from dating and calling apps to meme-makers to TikTok, Twitter and Clubhouse rivals to apps for couples and more. Now, NPE will begin testing out a new thesis: that the next big idea may come from a market outside the U.S.
OKCoin has allocated $1 million to encourage more women to enter the cryptocurrency space and has hired Randi Zuckerberg to lead the effort.
Jayda Cheaves is a flourishing social media influencer and entrepreneur who too often gets stigmatized over her dating and social life.
FOX 35's Andrea Jackson talks to experts to help you avoid gift exchange scams on social media this holiday season.
The Federal Trade Commission announced Thursday it was suing Nvidia over its $40 billion purchase of Arm, the largest acquisition of a semiconductor chip design company.Arm, owned by Tokyo-based Softbank, produces designs and computing technology for semiconductor chips, which are used to power most tech devices, from Iphones and laptops to computer systems in most vehicles.In a statement, the FTC argued that if the California-based Nvidia -…
A federal judge has dismissed a $10 billion lawsuit brought by media executive Byron Allen’s companies against McDonald’s that accused the fast-food chain of racially discriminatory contracting and spending.
(Bloomberg) — As many as 4.1 million people working through food delivery and ride-hailing apps could be reclassified as employees under a forthcoming European Union plan meant to improve gig workers’ labor rights.Most Read from BloombergThe Hot New Trend For Hedge Funds Is—Finally—Female Founders‘Ghost Signs’ Haunt London’s Reviving NeighborhoodsReliving the New York Subway Map DebateAutomating the War on Noise Pollution‘Pension Poachers’ Are Targeting America’s Elderly VeteransThe draft propo
Apple shares opened lower on Thursday over concerns of upcoming demand for its iPhone. The tech giant reportedly told suppliers pent up orders may not be as strong as expected going into the holiday season.
It can be dangerous to invest retirement-plan funds in esoteric assets without proper guidance. A husband and wife in Rhode Island have learned that lesson the hard way.
Moves by Parag Agrawal quickly follow the departure of Jack Dorsey late last month.
(Bloomberg) — Inside an expansive and noisy distribution center just east of Atlanta, Home Depot Inc. is trying to solve a problem that’s plaguing its stores: large orders from pro shoppers. Most Read from BloombergReliving the New York Subway Map Debate‘Ghost Signs’ Haunt London’s Reviving NeighborhoodsAutomating the War on Noise PollutionChina Cash Flowed Through Congo Bank to Former President’s Cronies‘Pension Poachers’ Are Targeting America’s Elderly VeteransContractors’ needs are very diff
In 2019, PepsiCo sued some Indian farmers based in the western state of Gujarat for cultivating the FC5 potato variety, which has a lower moisture content required to make snacks such as potato chips. Withdrawing the lawsuits the same year, the New York-based company said it wanted to settle the issue amicably.
If you were planning to do a “Roth IRA” conversion to keep your retirement savings permanently out of the hands of the IRS, you might want to get on it. The new tax bill on Capitol Hill is going to scrap these conversions for everybody after the end of the year — and, no, not just for those earning more than $400,000 a year. The bill “prohibits all employee after-tax contributions in qualified plans and prohibits after-tax IRA contributions from being converted to Roth regardless of income level, effective for distributions, transfers, and contributions made after Dec. 31, 2021,” reports the House Ways & Means Committee.